Old Navy Extra-High Waisted Sky-Hi Straight Raw-Edge Jeans
The item: Old Navy Extra-High Waisted Sky-Hi Straight Raw-Edge Jeans ($35, originally $40)
What our editor said: "I can't tell you how many times I've seen someone wearing cool vintage-looking jeans and wanted them for myself. Alt, every time I bought a pair or tried them on, they never fit my body (or butt, to be exact) quite right. Thankfully, my never-ending search just came to an end when I found these." — KJ
If you want to read more, here is the complete review.