"A River of Candy Corn Runs Through It," Season 2
Libby brags about her upcoming Halloween party (and of course doesn't invite Sabrina and her BFF Valerie), so Valerie announces that Sabrina's throwing "an even cooler party" at her house. Much to Sabrina's chagrin, her aunts are stoked about throwing a Halloween bash, but once the Spellmans' new furniture starts talking, Hilda makes too much candy corn, and a group of Halloween carolers from the Other Realm stop by, Sabrina is convinced the party will be ruined. On the contrary, her classmates think all the effects are fake (and amazing!), and she ends up looking like the best party host ever. Oh, and the band 10,000 Maniacs performs, which is just so perfectly '90s.